Rent or Buy? What is the Best Option for Building Long Term Wealth?

When it comes to wealth building, renting or buying a home offers two distinct paths. Depending on your situation, either path can actually be good to build wealth over time. We'll discuss the pros and cons of each option.

Introduction

In today’s world, the age-old debate of whether to rent or buy a home is a highly contested one. On one hand, renting can provide a certain level of flexibility and affordability, but on the other hand, buying a home can be a great way to build wealth over time.

This article will explore the pros and cons of each option, and provide helpful advice on which route may be best for building long-term financial stability.

Definition of rent versus buy

Renting a property means that you are paying a set amount of money in exchange for the right to live in a property for a specific period of time. The property remains the property of the landlord and the tenant has no right to own the property.

Buying a property means that you are paying a set amount of money for full ownership of the property. This means that you become the legal owner of the property and have the right to do with it as you please.

Overview of wealth building

Home ownership is one of the most valuable and effective ways to build wealth over time. By putting your hard-earned money into an appreciating asset – your home – you are investing in your future. With each mortgage payment, you are building equity in your home, which can be used to make improvements, pay for college tuition, or even to buy another property.

Not only can you build equity in your home, but you can also benefit from tax deductions, a stable monthly payment, and the potential for capital gains when you eventually sell. Home ownership also allows you to build a sense of community, as well as a sense of pride in a place you can call your own. With careful planning and dedication, home ownership can be a great way to build financial security and create wealth for the future.

On the flip side, you can also build wealth while renting by investing the cash you would have used for the down payment. Also, if the rent payment is lower than what you would spend on a monthly housing payment, you can invest that difference as well to help your wealth grow even more. Having the discipline to invest while renting a home can be a huge benefit because there is no down payment to rent (other than the security deposit) and the rent is usually lower than the mortgage payment on a home.

Additionally, you could use the extra funds to pay off any existing high interest debt, which can help improve your credit score and financial standing. Ultimately, investing while renting can be a great way to build wealth as long as you are mindful of the risks associated with any type of investment.

Cost of rent & potential rent increases

When renting, it is important to consider the cost of rent and potential rent increases. As with home prices, rent costs tend to increase over time with inflation. Be sure to compare the cost of rent between different properties and factor in potential rent increases when making a decision. Differences in rent might seem small, but over time they can add up to a huge sum.

Also, consider the possibility of rent increases over the years, whether they are fixed or variable. Fixed rent increases are typically predetermined and agreed upon by both the tenant and the landlord. Variable rent increases, however, are determined by the landlord and can change annually or even more frequently. Make sure to negotiate rent increases with your landlord upfront and also keep an eye out for any changes in the local real estate market that could affect future rent increases.

The flexibility of renting

The flexibility of renting can be a great benefit for some people. It allows for short-term leases, which can be helpful for those who are unsure of their future plans or who may need to move quickly for work or other reasons.

Additionally, renting can often provide more flexibility in terms of the types of amenities that are included. With a rental, you may have the option to choose different levels of furnishings or upgrades to the property, and you may also have the ability to customize the space to meet your needs.

Finally, renting can give you the chance to explore different neighborhoods and cities without the commitment of buying a home. This can be invaluable for those who are looking to find the perfect place to settle down.

Maintenance and repair responsibilities

When renting, it is important to verify who is responsible for maintenance and repair. Depending on the type of rental agreement, the tenant or the landlord may be responsible for certain repairs.

In some cases, landlords are responsible for repairs to the structure of the property, and tenants are responsible for minor repairs such as replacing light bulbs, cleaning the air conditioning filters, and taking care of minor plumbing issues.

Review the rental agreement to understand who is responsible for what and to ensure that all responsibilities are clearly defined. It is also valuable to know when the landlord or tenant needs to notify the other of any repair needs. Make sure to keep all receipts of any repair costs so that it can be tracked in case of any disputes.

Upfront costs and appreciation

When it comes to purchasing a home, upfront costs and appreciation are two of the biggest factors to consider. Upfront costs refer to the down payment, closing costs, and inspection fees. These costs can vary greatly depending on the type of loan you choose, the size and location of the home, and the type of property you are buying. Appreciation refers to the increase in the home’s value over time.

Homes that are in desirable locations, have been updated and maintained, or are located in areas with increasing property values typically appreciate more than homes that lack such features. The potential for appreciation when selecting a home is a very important factor as it can significantly affect the return on investment you get from the purchase.

Tax advantages

Owning a home can bring many tax advantages to the homeowner. On the federal level, homeowners may be able to deduct mortgage interest payments, property taxes, and other related expenses on their income tax return.

Additionally, the federal government may offer a tax credit for first-time homebuyers. On the state and local levels, there may be additional tax credits and deductions available to homeowners.

You must be able to itemize the deductions on your tax return to take full advantage of the tax benefits of homeownership. If the mortgage interest, property taxes, and other deductible items do not exceed your standard deduction, you are not receiving one of the largest available tax breaks for home owners.

Building of equity

Building of equity is a crucial factor to consider for wealth building through home ownership. Equity is essentially the value of your home minus the amount you owe on it.

When you make a mortgage payment, you are essentially paying down the loan principal balance and increasing the amount of equity you have in your home. As you pay down the loan over time, the amount of equity in your home will increase. This equity can be borrowed against it in the future or returned to you in cash once you sell the home.

For example, if you need to make home improvements or need extra money for other expenses, you can use the equity in your home to qualify for an additional loan. When you decide to sell your home, you can use the equity to make a larger down payment on your next home.

Review of renting versus buying.

Renting versus buying is a difficult decision for many people. Both options have their own unique pros and cons, so it’s important to weigh the differences carefully before making a commitment.

Renting can be a great option for those who want the flexibility of changing homes or locations in a relatively short time. It almost always requires a smaller upfront investment than buying and you don’t have the responsibility of repairs or maintenance. However, you are usually restricted in terms of modifications you can make to the property, and the amount of rent you pay each month goes to your landlord to pay their mortgage instead of your own.

Buying a home should be considered more of a long-term investment and I define that as at least 4-5 years. So you’ll need to be sure you are comfortable with staying in the same place for a while or at least not selling in the short term. When you buy as an owner occupant, you just need to occupy the home for the first 12 months and then after that, can rent it out if you choose.

Upfront costs are usually higher when buying versus renting, but you can build equity over time and make changes to the property as you see fit. You’ll also need to factor in the costs of maintenance and repairs, which can be a significant expense, depending on the age and condition of the home. It is not uncommon to have to do roof repairs, repaint, replace major appliances or have a “surprise” plumbing issue that costs you thousands.

Overall, it’s important to carefully research and consider all of the factors before deciding whether renting or buying is the right choice for you. How long you plan to stay in the same location, your budget, investing goals and your lifestyle are all worthwhile considerations when making your decision.

Wealth building as a renter versus wealth building as a home owner.

Building wealth is not just limited to homeowners and buying a home is not for everyone all the time. Either option can be a great way to increase savings and create a financially secure future.

As a renter, you have the advantage of being able to move around more easily and avoid the risks associated with home ownership. You can also invest in things like stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and other instruments to start building wealth.

On the other hand, buying a home can be a great way to build equity and increase your net worth. You may have to make a significant upfront investment, but you can use the equity to make improvements to the home, or to borrow against it for other investments.

Ultimately, the decision to rent or own will depend on your lifestyle and financial goals, but both options can be a great way to start building wealth.

Ultimate Buy vs Rent Calculator – Considering Long Term Wealth Building

Ultimate Buy vs Rent Calculator – Considering Long Term Wealth Building

INSTRUCTIONS: Use this powerful calculator to estimate the additional wealth you will generate by either buying a home or renting and instead investing your down payment funds in the stock market. If your rent payment is lower than the after tax benefit housing payment for owning, then you can also calculate investing that difference in the market as well. Please complete all fields of this calculator to provide the most accurate results.

Home Buying Information

Has Buyer Used VA Loan Before?
Does Buyer Have VA Disability
$
$
$
$

Rental Information

$
$

Homebuyer Loan Information

$
%
%
%
$
%
%
$
$
6
30

Other Assumptions for Buying a Home

%
2023 Tax%   Single Filers      Married Filing Joint

12%      $11,000-$44,725     |      $22,000-$89,450

22%     $44,725-$95,375     |      $89,450-$190,750

24%     $95,375-$182,100   |     $190,750-$364,200

32%     $182,100-$231,250 |     $364,200-$462,500

35%     $231,250-$578,125 |      $462,500-$693,750

37%     $578,125 or more    |     $693,750 or more

$
$
%
%

Costs Associated with Home Ownership

$.00
$.00
$.00
$.00

This field automatically calculates the PMI as a percentage of your loan amount annually based on credit score and loan to value. The monthly dollar amount of PMI is expressed in the Financial Analysis Section below.

%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%

Other Assumptions for Renting

%
%
If RENT is less than after-tax monthly housing payment, will you invest the difference?
$

Home Ownership Monthly Expenses

Please Note: the Total Monthly Payment below auto-populates the data as it is entered.  Be sure to click out of an entry field to ensure it is included in the calculations.

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

Financial Analysis – Rent vs Buy

$
$
$

$

$

$

$

This is your calculated net proceeds from selling your home after taking into account remaining mortgage loan payoff balance, expenses associated with home ownership (ie HOA dues, insurance, property taxes, and repairs/maintenance) and closing costs associated with buying and selling the home.

This is calculated using your input for annual rate of appreciation and Timeframe for number of years.

This is the future value of investing the down payment and closing costs instead of using for the purchase of a home.  If you answered “yes” to investing the after tax monthly difference between the home ownership payment and monthly rent, then this additional investment is included.

This is calculated using your input for annual rate of return and Timeframe for number of years.

$

$

Add Your Heading Text Here

Picture of Jay Miller

Jay Miller

Certified Mortgage Planning Specialist (CMPS) with more than 22 years residential mortgage experience. Looking to buy a new home or invest in real estate but feeling lost in the maze of mortgage qualification and personal finance? Don't worry, I've got you covered! My mission is to take the mystery out of the home buying experience and empower you with the knowledge you need to make informed financial decisions. It's true, most of us are never taught about credit or personal finance in school and many lenders fall short when it comes to providing educational guidance. But fear not, because with my guidance, you'll be well-equipped to navigate the housing market with confidence. Whether you're a first-time home buyer or a seasoned real estate investor, my goal is to arm you with the tools and information you need to make the right financial choices for you and your family. I'm always looking for feedback and eager to assist you on your home buying journey.